​Do I Need a Lawyer or an HR Consultant to Terminate an Employee?

Learn whether you need an HR consultant or a lawyer to terminate an employee. Practical guidance for Newcastle businesses on risk, process and compliance.

Introduction

If you’ve ever Googled how to terminate an employee, you’ve probably noticed that most of the top results come from law firms. For many Newcastle and Hunter Valley business owners, that can make a straightforward HR issue feel like a legal emergency. It’s completely understandable to worry about cost, compliance, and the risk of an unfair dismissal claim, especially when you’re time-poor and simply want to handle the situation properly.
This article will help you work out whether you need HR support, an employment lawyer, or a combination of both. You’ll get a clear, practical framework to assess risk before spending money unnecessarily, with guidance tailored to Australian small and medium businesses, particularly those operating in NSW.

Disclaimer: This article is general information only and does not constitute legal advice.

What an HR Consultancy Typically Helps With

A qualified HR consultant supports employers to manage people issues in a structured, compliant and practical way. This includes guiding businesses through performance management and termination processes to ensure procedural fairness, appropriate documentation, and clear communication.  
By getting the process right from the outset, HR support helps ensure that any decision to terminate employment is fair and defensible, significantly reducing the risk of a successful unfair dismissal or general protections claim.  

For many small businesses without an internal HR team, this is the most accessible and cost‑effective form of support.

Common areas where HR consultants assist include:

• Performance management processes (including attending meetings and drafting letters, warnings, and performance improvement plans)  
• Redundancy advice and support  
• Unfair dismissal and general protection matters up to and including conciliation  
• Supporting employers to settle potential claims

Why this matters

HR consultants focus on process, people management, and prevention. In Newcastle, many businesses rely on outsourced HR support for exactly this reason. HR Consultants can provide a structured, compliant pathway through performance issues and terminations without immediately escalating matters to legal advice.

Engaging HR support early can help employers understand their obligations, document decisions properly, and manage conversations with clarity and fairness, often preventing issues from becoming formal disputes.

What an Employment Lawyer Typically Helps With

Employment lawyers step in when the risk profile is higher, the situation is complex, or there is a genuine likelihood of legal proceedings.  

Lawyers typically assist with:

• Complex employee relations issues involving competing legal considerations  
• Fair Work Commission or court matters requiring formal representation

Why this matters

Lawyers focus on legal exposure and defence. They are the right choice when litigation is likely, when the situation is sensitive, or when you’re unsure whether past actions may have created risk.
HR and legal support often work best together. In practice, HR consultants like Skildare help businesses gather facts, document processes, and clarify timelines, making any legal advice more efficient and better informed.

Decision Guide: Who Should You Call?

​Experienced HR consultants like Skildare can manage most employee matters from start to finish, including process guidance, documentation, communication, and risk management.

In many situations, HR support is the most practical and cost effective first step, particularly where the matter relates to:

• Performance concerns
• Conduct issues
• Procedural fairness
• Documentation gaps
• Short service employees
• Day to day people management challenges

At times, to help protect your business, we may recommend seeking additional legal advice where the situation carries heightened legal complexity or litigation risk.  This may include matters involving:

• Proposed summary dismissal for serious misconduct
• Threatened claims or formal complaints
• Discrimination, pregnancy, injury, mental health, or adverse action risks
• Complex redundancies or high risk terminations
• Unclear procedural history or earlier process concerns
• Employees represented by lawyers, unions, or external advocates

In these scenarios, the most effective approach is often a combined one, with Skildare managing the process and practical steps, while legal advice supports strategy where required.  

​Conclusion

Not every tricky HR situation or termination requires a lawyer. Many performance‑based or low‑risk matters can be managed effectively with the support of an HR consultant or outsourced HR provider. But when the situation is complex, sensitive, or escalating, legal advice becomes an important safeguard.

The key is choosing the right support at the right time — calmly, confidently, and with a clear understanding of your options.

Disclaimer: This article is general information only and does not constitute legal advice.

Need clarity on a termination or performance issue

Skildare supports Newcastle businesses with practical, process‑driven HR guidance so you can make confident, compliant decisions. If you’re unsure whether your situation requires HR support, legal advice, or both, we can help you assess the risk and plan the next steps.

Start with a confidential conversation - book a free discovery call.

       

       if(window.strchfSettings === undefined) window.strchfSettings = {};
   window.strchfSettings.stats = {url: "https://skildare.storychief.io/en/do-i-need-a-lawyer-or-an-hr-consultant-to-terminate-an-employee?id=4351883&type=26",title: "​Do I Need a Lawyer or an HR Consultant to Terminate an Employee?",siteId: "25040",id: ""};
           (function(d, s, id) {
     var js, sjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
     if (d.getElementById(id)) {window.strchf.update(); return;}
     js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id;
     js.src = "https://d37oebn0w9ir6a.cloudfront.net/scripts/v0/strchf.js";
     js.async = true;
     sjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, sjs);
   }(document, 'script', 'storychief-jssdk'))